DWI Arrest Without Field Sobriety Test in Texas

Summary:

A DWI arrest without field sobriety tests (FSTs) presents unique legal challenges in Texas, where officers may rely on other evidence like erratic driving, admissions, or blood/Breathalyzer results. Immediately affected individuals face rapid driver’s license suspension, incarceration, and financial strain, while businesses risk liability if employees drive company vehicles under the influence. The absence of FSTs creates both risks (reduced defense evidence) and opportunities (challenging probable cause). Texas’ strict implied consent laws and no-refusal weekends heighten complexities, requiring immediate legal action to protect driving privileges and counter prosecution strategies built entirely on chemical tests or officer observations.

What This Means for You:

• Immediate Action: Contact a DWI attorney within 15 days of arrest to request an ALR (Administrative License Revocation) hearing with the Texas Department of Public Safety (per Texas Transportation Code §724.041). Failure to act automatically suspends your license 40 days post-arrest.
• Legal Risks: Even without FSTs, first-time DWI convictions carry up to 180 days jail (3 days mandatory if BAC ≥0.15), $3,000 fines, and 90-365 day license suspension. Enhanced penalties apply for BAC ≥0.15 (Class A misdemeanor), prior convictions (felony for 3+ offenses), or accidents causing injury/death.
• Financial Impact: Expect $10,000-$17,000 in total costs including attorney fees ($3,500-$12,000), court fines ($2,000+), 3-year SR-22 insurance ($2,500/yr), DWI education programs ($450), ignition interlock installation/maintenance ($900/yr), and occupational license fees ($300).
• Long-Term Strategy: Petition for non-disclosure after mandatory waiting periods (2+ years for first offenses under Texas Gov’t Code §411.0731) to limit public visibility. Commercial drivers should pursue occupational licenses early and document rehabilitation efforts to mitigate CDL impacts under FMCSA 49 CFR §382.

Explained: DWI Arrest Without Field Sobriety Test in Texas:

Under Texas Penal Code §49.04, a DWI arrest without FSTs is legally valid if officers establish probable cause through alternative evidence like speeding, swerving, slurred speech, alcohol containers in vehicle, or failed chemical tests. Texas courts uphold arrests based on “totality of circumstances” (State v. Cullen, 2015). Unlike standardized FSTs (walk-and-turn, one-leg stand, HGN), officers may cite non-standardized indicators like inability to follow instructions, erratic behavior at traffic stops, or performance during modified Romberg balance tests.

Pursuant to Texas Transportation Code §724.012 (Implied Consent), refusing Breathalyzer/Blood tests triggers automatic license suspension – yet police may obtain warrants for forced blood draws in no-refusal jurisdictions. A valid warrant negates refusal penalties but provides prosecutors definitive BAC evidence. The absence of FST video evidence often shifts trial focus to technical challenges of blood draw protocols and chain-of-custody documentation.

Types of DWI Offenses:

Texas recognizes five DWI charge tiers where arrests occur without FSTs: 1) Standard DWI (BAC ≥0.08), 2) DWI with Child Passenger (state jail felony), 3) Intoxication Assault (3rd-degree felony for serious injury), 4) Intoxication Manslaughter (2nd-degree felony), and 5) Boating While Intoxicated (Parks & Wildlife Code §49.06). Commercial drivers face enhanced sanctions at ≥0.04 BAC under Texas Alcoholic Beverage Code §106.041.

“Per se” DWI charges rely solely on BAC results, while “impairment” charges apply to prescription drug/DUID cases where BAC isn’t elevated but driving demonstrates substantial deviation from normal use. Officers increasingly use drug recognition experts (DREs) in lieu of FSTs for pharmaceutical/cannabis cases.

Common Defences for DWI:

1) Suppression Motions: Challenge the traffic stop’s legality under Fourth Amendment principles. If officers lacked reasonable suspicion for the initial stop (e.g., faulty equipment tag lights), subsequent evidence is inadmissible (Basset v. State, 2018).
2) Rising BAC Defense: Prove alcohol consumption occurred just before driving, meaning BAC was below 0.08 during operation but rose during processing. Requires forensic toxicology testimony.
3) Medical Conditions: Diabetics, GERD sufferers, and epilepsy patients may generate false BAC readings or exhibit symptoms mimicking intoxication. Denture wearers disproportionately fail Breathalyzers due to residual alcohol in oral cavities.
4) Blood Test Challenges: Attack phlebotomist certification, anticoagulant/ preservative vial errors, or improper storage. Texas requires blood draws by qualified technicians under OCCC Rule 19.

Penalties and Consequences of DWI Offenses:

First Offense: 72 hours to 180 days jail (6 months mandatory if open container present), $3,000 fine, 90-day license suspension (180 days if BAC ≥0.15). Second Offense: 30 days to 1 year jail, $4,500 fine, 180-day suspension. Third Offense: 2-10 years prison (felony), $10,000 fine, 180-day suspension. Collateral consequences include 24-month ignition interlock requirement, 3-year SR-22 insurance filing, mandatory 12-hour DWI education ($200), and potential vehicle forfeiture for repeat offenses.

Enhanced penalties apply for school zones (double fines), passengers under 15 (child endangerment charges), or commercial vehicle operation (1-year CDL revocation). Lifetime criminal records create employment barriers in healthcare, education, and transportation sectors. Non-citizens face deportation proceedings for felony convictions under INA §237.

The DWI Legal Process:

1) Arrest & Booking: Following initial roadside investigation, suspect is transported for chemical testing. Refusal triggers automatic license suspension unless ALR hearing requested within 15 days.
2) ALR Hearing (Separate from Criminal Case): Administrative law judge determines if license suspension is justified based on probable cause and test refusal/compliance. Successful challenges reverse suspension but don’t dismiss criminal charges.
3) Arraignment (14-30 Days Post-Arrest): Defendant appears to hear formal charges and enter plea. Conditions like SCRAM monitoring may be imposed pre-trial.
4) Pre-Trial Motions (3-5 Months): Defense files motions to suppress evidence, dismiss charges, or compel discovery (bodycam footage, maintenance logs for Breathalyzer devices). Prosecution discloses expert witnesses.
5) Plea Bargaining: Over 85% of Texas DWI cases resolve via plea to reduced charges like “Obstruction of Highway” or deferred adjudication. Prosecutors rarely offer dismissals without evidentiary flaws.
6) Trial (8-14 Months Post-Arrest): Jury trials focus on officer credibility, scientific evidence reliability, and reasonable doubt about impairment timing/severity. Trials lacking FSTs turn on technical BAC evidence disputes.
7) Sentencing: Judges impose penalties per statutory minimums unless probation terms (community service, AA attendance) are negotiated.

Choosing a DWI Attorney:

Select a Texas Board of Legal Specialization-certified DWI attorney with specific experience challenging blood/Breathalyzer results. Verify (a) membership in Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association (TCDLA), (b) familiarity with local prosecutors’ plea policies, and (c) trial experience against regional breath test technical supervisors (BTTs). Avoid attorneys using volume plea mills; flat fees ($3,500+) demonstrate commitment over low-bid contingency models. Prioritize firms employing independent forensic toxicologists and accident reconstructionists for blood analysis challenge support.

Other DWI Resources:

1) Texas Department of Public Safety ALR Portal: https://www.dps.texas.gov/section/driver-license/alr-hearings
2) Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association DWI Resources: https://www.tcdla.com/resources/dwi-resources/

People Also Ask:

1. Can police make a DWI arrest without field sobriety tests in Texas?
Yes. Texas courts allow DWI arrests based on any credible evidence of impairment under Penal Code §49.04 – including speeding 20+ mph over limit (State v. Zeno, 2020), admissions of drinking, bloodshot eyes, or failed Breathalyzer tests. FSTs are optional investigative tools, not legal requirements.

2. Should I refuse both FSTs and Breathalyzer tests?
Refusing FSTs is generally advisable (no legal penalty), but refusing Breathalyzer/blood tests under Texas Transportation Code §724.035 triggers automatic license suspension. Officers will likely obtain warrants for blood draws in no-refusal jurisdictions, creating stronger evidence against you.

3. How do you beat a DWI with no field sobriety test?
Success requires attacking alternative evidence: (1) challenge traffic stop legality (“Whren violation” if pretextual stop), (2) dispute Breathalyzer calibration/maintenance records per Texas Administrative Code Rule 19, (3) prove rising BAC defense with toxicologist testimony, or (4) demonstrate medical conditions affecting officer observations (hypoglycemia mimicking intoxication).

4. What happens if you refuse a blood test in Texas?
Refusal triggers 180-day automatic license suspension (2 years for prior DWI), plus prosecutors may argue “consciousness of guilt” at trial. Officers will seek telephonic warrants for forced blood draws – refusal penalties apply even if warrant granted. Commercial drivers face 1-year CDL revocation for any test refusal.

5. How long does Texas have to file DWI charges?
Misdemeanor DWI charges must be filed within 2 years (Code of Criminal Procedure Art. 12.02), felony DWI within 3 years. However, license suspensions through ALR process begin within 40 days unless hearing requested within 15 days of arrest.

Expert Opinion:

Defendants underestimate prosecutorial advantages when DWI arrests occur without FST evidence, as Texas juries disproportionately trust officer testimony and chemical test results. Immediately retaining counsel skilled in toxicology report cross-examination is critical, as successful ALR hearing outcomes statistically correlate with reduced criminal conviction rates. Strategic challenges to blood draw warrants and state-run breath test program violations offer the highest dismissal opportunities.

Key Terms:

• Texas DWI arrest no field sobriety test probable cause
• Fight ALR hearing license suspension Texas DPS
• Chemical test refusal penalties Texas Transportation Code 724
• Intoxication manslaughter Texas felony defense
• Breathalyzer calibration errors Texas DWI case
• Houston DWI attorney blood warrant challenge
• Texas implied consent law officer requirements

*featured image sourced by Pixabay.com