DWI Roadside Test Refusal in Texas

Summary:

Refusing a roadside test during a DWI stop in Texas carries immediate and long-term legal and financial consequences. Under Texas’ implied consent law (Transportation Code §724.011), drivers automatically consent to breath or blood tests if arrested for DWI—refusal triggers automatic license suspension, even if no criminal conviction occurs. For commercial drivers, refusal can jeopardize CDL privileges and employment. Unique challenges include enhanced civil penalties, evidentiary hurdles for prosecutors, and potential ignition interlock requirements. Legal risks escalate with prior offenses, leading to mandatory minimum jail time, extended suspensions, and felony charges. Understanding these nuances is critical for anyone facing refusal allegations.

What This Means for You:

• Immediate Action: Request an Administrative License Revocation (ALR) hearing within 15 days of arrest to contest suspension under Texas Transportation Code §724.041. Retain a DWI defense attorney immediately—delay forfeits this right automatically. Securing legal counsel before interacting with prosecutors preserves defenses like improper stop justification or medical exceptions to refusal penalties.
• Legal Risks: Criminal penalties range from Class B misdemeanor (first refusal) to felony charges (third+) with 2-10 years prison. Refusal alone triggers a 180-day license suspension (first offense) or 2 years for prior DWIs. Enhanced penalties apply if BAC exceeds 0.15 or minors are present. Prosecutors use refusal as “consciousness of guilt” evidence at trial, weakening defense strategies.
• Financial Impact: Expect $4,000-$15,000 in fines, legal fees, and court costs; 3-year SR-22 insurance averaging $3,000 annually; $1,000+ ignition interlock installation/maintenance fees; and lost wages from suspended licenses. Commercial drivers face job termination, costing $50,000+ annually in income loss.
• Long-Term Strategy: Pursue non-disclosure eligibility (5-year wait post-conviction) to shield employment records. Complete court-ordered DWI education programs (DWIEC) or substance abuse treatment early to demonstrate rehabilitation. Consult attorneys about challenging ALR suspensions via procedural errors (lack of reasonable suspicion) to restore driving privileges.

Explained: DWI Roadside Test Refusal in Texas

Under Texas Transportation Code §724.011, implied consent means any driver arrested for DWI must submit to breath or blood testing. Refusing a roadside sobriety test (SFSTs) is not criminally penalized, but declining post-arrest chemical testing violates implied consent, resulting in automatic administrative license suspension. The legal blood alcohol concentration (BAC) limit is 0.08% for adults and 0.04% for commercial drivers, per Texas Penal Code §49.01. Federal guidelines (23 USC §163) tie highway funding to state adherence to DWI enforcement, reinforcing strict refusal penalties.

Texas case law (State v. Villarreal, 2014) affirms warrantless blood draws are unconstitutional without exigent circumstances; however, refusal still incurs separate civil penalties. Prosecutors often argue refusal indicates guilt under Bartlett v. State (2016), though skilled attorneys counter with medical conditions (e.g., asthma invalidating breath tests) or procedural errors during arrest.

Types of DWI Offenses:

DWI refusal charges vary by severity: Class B misdemeanor (first refusal, no aggravators), Class A (BAC ≥0.15 or open container), or felony (prior convictions or accidents causing injury). Commercial DWI refusal under Texas Penal Code §49.09 enhances penalties—CDL holders face one-year disqualification for refusal (§522.105). Repeat offenders risk permanent CDL revocation. Intoxication assault/refusal (Penal Code §49.07) escalates to third-degree felony with 2-10 years prison if refusal accompanies serious bodily injury.

“No refusal” initiatives—common in Travis or Harris counties—allow expedited tele-warrants for forced blood draws if drivers refuse testing. These programs reduce evidentiary gaps but face Fourth Amendment challenges. Underage refusal (Texas Alcoholic Beverage Code §106.041) applies zero-tolerance policies: any detectable alcohol triggers suspension, and refusals are treated as violations regardless of BAC.

Common Defences for DWI:

Defenses target three stages: arrest validity, refusal justification, and procedural integrity. Challenge the initial stop by proving lack of reasonable suspicion (e.g., improper lane change claims via dashcam footage). Argue medical inability—diabetics may produce false BAC readings; COPD patients cannot complete breath tests. Officers must inform drivers of refusal consequences in their primary language; faulty advisements (Castro v. State, 2018) invalidate suspensions. Contest warrantless blood draws using Missouri v. McNeely (2013), which mandates case-specific exigency.

Attack ALR suspensions by demonstrating the officer lacked probable cause for arrest. Prior to refusal, Texas requires a 15-minute observation period to prevent mouth alcohol contamination—non-compliance voids test validity. Retaining experts to refute SFST reliability (e.g., nystagmus misattributed to alcohol) creates reasonable doubt.

Penalties and Consequences of DWI Offenses:

First refusal: 180-day license suspension, $2,000 fine, 3 days–6 months jail. Second refusal: 2-year suspension, $4,500 fine, 1 month–1 year jail. Third+ refusals become felonies (Texas Penal Code §49.09(b)), with 2-10 years prison and $10,000 fines. All convictions require $1,000 annual “DWI surcharge” for three years. Courts mandate ignition interlocks (minimum 1 year), and offenders pay installation ($100) and monthly fees ($80).

Collateral consequences include 2-5 years loss of firearm rights (18 USC §922(g)), international travel bans (Canada’s Immigration Act), and professional license suspensions (medical, legal). Employers may terminate workers for CDL disqualification or missed work due to suspended licenses. Apartment leases often exclude tenants with DWI convictions.

The DWI Legal Process:

Post-arrest, officers issue a Notice of Suspension and confiscate licenses. Drivers have 15 days to request ALR hearings to contest suspension—failure waives appeal rights. Criminal arraignment follows, where pleas are entered (typically “not guilty”). Pre-trial discovery examines officer credentials, calibration records, and bodycam footage. Motions to suppress focus on unlawful stops or Miranda violations.

Plea bargaining often reduces refusal charges to “obstruction of highway” (Penal Code §42.03) to avoid suspensions. If proceeding to trial, defenses emphasize the state’s lack of BAC evidence. Sentencing mandates DWI education programs (12-32 hours) and community service (24-100 hours). Appeals must be filed within 30 days of conviction.

Choosing a DWI Attorney:

Select board-certified DWI specialists recognized by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization. Verify their ALR hearing win rates and familiarity with local judges (e.g., Harris County’s specialty courts). Attorneys should subpoena arresting officers’ disciplinary records—prior misconduct can disqualify testimony. Flat-fee structures ($7,500-$25,000) are preferable to hourly billing. Ensure they coordinate with toxicologists to challenge blood test chain-of-custody errors.

Other DWI Resources:

Texas Department of Public Safety provides ALR hearing guidelines. The Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association offers DWI defense resources.

People Also Ask:

Can I refuse a breathalyzer in Texas without penalty?
You may refuse a preliminary breath test (PBT) during initial stops without criminal penalty, as PBTs aren’t covered under implied consent laws. However, refusing post-arrest chemical tests (blood or breath) automatically suspends your license for 180 days. Officers may obtain warrants for forced blood draws if they suspect intoxication.

Will refusal keep a DWI off my record?
Refusal doesn’t prevent a DWI charge—prosecutors can file charges based on officer observations (slurred speech, failed sobriety tests). While refusal deprives the state of BAC evidence, it introduces harsher administrative penalties and allows prosecutors to imply guilt to juries.

How long does a refusal stay on your driving record?
Administrative refusals remain on your Texas driving record indefinitely but only affect insurance rates for three years. Criminal convictions appear permanently unless expunged (for dismissed cases) or sealed via nondisclosure (eligibility begins five years post-conviction for misdemeanors).

Expert Opinion:

Addressing a DWI refusal charge immediately is critical—administrative suspensions proceed independently of criminal cases, creating separate legal battles. Early intervention by specialized counsel preserves driving privileges, weakens prosecutorial leverage, and mitigates employment disruptions. Strategic challenges to implied consent warnings or blood draw protocols often yield dismissals where field evidence is weak.

Key Terms:

• Texas DWI implied consent law
• Administrative License Revocation hearing
• DWI refusal penalties in Texas
• ALR hearing defense strategies
• DWI surcharge costs Texas
• Texas felony DWI refusal
• Choosing a DWI attorney Houston

*featured image sourced by Pixabay.com